Court

At the Supreme Court, when is immigration advice a crime? : NPR

At the Supreme Court, when is immigration advice a crime? : NPR
At the Supreme Court, when is immigration advice a crime? : NPR

The issue before the Supreme Court on Monday: whether a federal law that prohibits inducing unlawful immigration for financial gain violates the First Amendment.

Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times via Getty Imag


hide caption

toggle caption

Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times via Getty Imag


The issue before the Supreme Court on Monday: whether a federal law that prohibits inducing unlawful immigration for financial gain violates the First Amendment.

Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times via Getty Imag

Look at the the Supreme Court’s history, and you will see a lot of cases in which odious defendants bring tough First Amendment questions. Monday’s case was one of those.

The issue was whether a federal law that makes it a crime to encourage or induce illegal immigration transforms some speech protected by the Constitution into a crime.

The defendant in this case is Helaman Hansen, who conned 471 noncitizens into believing that they could obtain U.S.

Read More